UPDATE: I have posted an update to this article here: More boot storm details

Measuring the benefit of cache deduplication with a real world workload can be very difficult unless you try it in production. I have written about the theory in the past and I did a lab test here with highly duplicate synthetic data. The results were revealing about how the NetApp deduplication technology impacts both read cache and disk. Based on our findings, we decided to run another test. This time the plan was to test NetApp deduplication with a VMware guest boot storm. We also added the NetApp Performance Accelerator Module (PAM) to the testing.

The test infrastructure consists of 4 dual socket Intel Nehalem servers with 48GB of RAM each. Each server is connected to a 10GbE switch. A FAS3170 is connected to the same 10GbE switch. There are 200 virtual machines: 50 Microsoft Windows 2003, 50 Microsoft Vista, 50 Microsoft Windows 2008, and 50 linux. Each operating system type is installed in a separate NetApp FlexVol for a total of 4 volumes. This was not done to maximize the deduplication results. Instead we did it to allow the VMware systems to use 4 different NFS datastores. Each physical server mounts all 4 NFS datastores and the guests were split evenly across the 4 physical servers.

The test consisted of booting all 200 guests simultaneously. This test was run multiple times with the FAS 3170 cache warm and cold, with deduplication and without, and with PAM and without. Here is a table summarizing the boot timing results. This is the amount of time between starting the boot and the 200th system acquiring an IP address. Here are the results: Read more…